Federal Supreme Court Judgment on Mandatory Confiscation and Publication in Commercial Fraud Penalties
Federal Supreme Court
Judgment summary
In Penal Appeal No. 409 of 2026, the UAE Federal Supreme Court examined a judgment convicting a defendant of commercial fraud for storing counterfeit goods intended for resale. The lower courts imposed a fine of AED 5,000 but omitted mandatory supplementary penalties. The Public Prosecution appealed, contending that Article 19 of Federal Decree-Law No. 42 of 2023 on Combating Commercial Fraud obligates the court to order the confiscation or destruction of seized counterfeit items and the publication of the conviction summary in two local daily newspapers at the convict's expense. Upholding the prosecution's challenge, the Supreme Court ruled that mandatory supplementary penalties cannot be omitted once guilt is established. Exercising its corrective authority under Article 249(2) of the Criminal Procedures Law, the Court partially reversed the judgment and amended the sentence to include confiscation and newspaper publication alongside the original fine.
United Arab Emirates - The Federal Supreme Court
Session: Wednesday, 16 September 2026
Presiding: Judge Ahmed Rashid Al-Salman, President of the Chamber
Members: Judge Galal Mohamed Ezzat Hegazy and Judge Dr. Akram Sayed Bakry Mahmoud
Penal Appeal No. 409 of 2026
Legal Principles
Law "Application". Penalty "Supplementary Penalty: Confiscation". Cassation "Authority of the Court of Cassation: Correcting Erroneous Legal Conclusions".
Confiscation of Seized Items: Confiscation is mandatory provided that their manufacture, use, possession, sale, or offer for sale constitutes an offense in itself. Confiscation of items and funds used in committing the offense or resulting therefrom is discretionary for the court. (Article 83 of the Crimes and Penalties Law).
Commercial Fraud Penalties: Ruling for the confiscation or destruction of counterfeit goods, materials, and tools used in the offense, and publishing a summary of the final conviction judgment in two local daily newspapers—one in Arabic—or by any other medium determined by the court at the expense of the convicted person, is mandatory on the court. (Article 19 of Federal Decree-Law No. 42 of 2023 on Combating Commercial Fraud).
Fulfilment of Legal Confiscation Grounds: Once the legal prerequisites for mandatory confiscation are fulfilled, ruling for it becomes compulsory. Grounds explained.
Omission of Mandatory Supplementary Penalty: Where seizure of counterfeit goods is established and the defendant is convicted of commercial fraud, the court must order their confiscation and the publication of the conviction summary. The lower court's omission of this supplementary penalty constitutes an error that the Federal Supreme Court may correct pursuant to Article 249(2) of the Criminal Procedures Law.
(Appeal No. 409 of 2026 Penal, Session of 16/09/2026)
Court Determinations
1. It is established in the jurisprudence of the Federal Supreme Court that Article 83 of the Crimes and Penalties Law mandates confiscation where the manufacture, use, possession, sale, or offering for sale of the seized items is in itself an offense, while granting the court discretion to confiscate items and funds used in committing the crime or obtained therefrom.
2. It is established in the jurisprudence of the Federal Supreme Court that Article 19 of Federal Decree-Law No. 42 of 2023 on Combating Commercial Fraud obligates the court to order the confiscation or destruction of counterfeit goods, materials, and equipment used in the offense, and to publish a summary of the final conviction judgment in two local daily newspapers—one in Arabic—or by any other means specified by the court, at the expense of the convicted person.
3. It is established in the jurisprudence of the Federal Supreme Court that where penal provisions are clear in meaning, they must be enforced in accordance with their express terms. Confiscation, when mandated by law, is an obligatory supplementary penalty that cannot be omitted following conviction and the satisfaction of its legal prerequisites.
4. Whereas the records of the challenged judgment indicate that it convicted the respondent of commercial fraud and established the seizure of the counterfeit goods, it failed to order their confiscation and the publication of the final judgment summary, despite Article 19(1) of Federal Decree-Law No. 42 of 2023 mandating both measures. As this error is limited to omitting mandatory supplementary penalties without affecting the conviction itself or the factual findings, the judgment must be partially reversed regarding the penalty. Acting on the merits under Article 249(2) of Federal Decree-Law No. 38 of 2022 on Criminal Procedures, the Court rectifies the judgment by ordering the confiscation of seized goods and newspaper publication in addition to the imposed fine.
The Court
Whereas the appeal has fulfilled all formal legal requirements;
Whereas the facts, as evidenced by the appealed judgment and case documents, show that the Public Prosecution referred the respondent to criminal trial on the charge that on 24/07/2024, within the jurisdiction of […]:
He stored counterfeit goods, as detailed in the investigation record, for the purpose of commercial fraud and resale, in the manner outlined in the papers;
The Public Prosecution requested the imposition of maximum penalties pursuant to Articles 1, 4(1)(a)(c), 5, 7, and 17 of Federal Decree-Law No. 42 of 2023 on Combating Commercial Fraud.
The Federal First Instance Court of […] delivered an in-person judgment on 02/03/2026, convicting the accused ([…], […] nationality) and ordering him to pay a fine of AED 5,000 for the attributed charge, together with judicial fees.
Neither the Public Prosecution nor the defendant accepted this verdict and appealed before the Federal Court of Appeal under Appeal Nos. […] and […] of 2026 Penal Appeal. At the hearing of 15/04/2026, the Court of Appeal ruled in presence of the parties to accept the appeals in form, reject them on the merits, uphold the appealed judgment, and order the appellant to pay judicial fees.
The Public Prosecution challenged that judgment by cassation, seeking to have the contested ruling quashed and remitted.
The Public Prosecution assigned error in the application of law to the appealed judgment, on the grounds that while it convicted the respondent of commercial fraud, it failed to order the confiscation of seized counterfeit merchandise or the publication of the final conviction summary in two local daily newspapers (one in Arabic), contrary to the mandatory provisions of Article 83 of the Crimes and Penalties Law and Article 19 of Federal Decree-Law No. 42 of 2023 on Combating Commercial Fraud, rendering the judgment defective and subject to cassation.
This argument is sound. Article 83 of the Crimes and Penalties Law mandates confiscation when the manufacture, use, possession, sale, or offer for sale of the seized goods constitutes an offense in itself, and permits confiscation of tools and proceeds used in or generated by the crime.
Furthermore, Article 19 of Federal Decree-Law No. 42 of 2023 on Combating Commercial Fraud mandates the confiscation or destruction of counterfeit goods, materials, and equipment used in the offense, and the publication of the final conviction judgment summary in two local daily newspapers—one in Arabic—or by any other court-determined medium, at the convict's expense. Criminal statutes with unambiguous text must be applied according to their express language. Where the law makes confiscation mandatory, it is an essential supplementary penalty that cannot be omitted following a finding of guilt and the presence of legal requirements. It is established from the judgment's records that:
The challenged judgment convicted the respondent of commercial fraud and established the seizure of the counterfeit goods involved in the offense, yet omitted to order their confiscation or the publication of the final conviction summary, despite Article 19(1) of Federal Decree-Law No. 42 of 2023 obligating the court to order both measures.
Since this judicial error was confined to the omission of mandatory supplementary penalties without impairing the established facts or the conviction itself, the judgment must be partially quashed regarding the penalty.
Addressing the merits pursuant to Article 249(2) of Federal Decree-Law No. 38 of 2022 Promulgating the Criminal Procedures Law, the Court rectifies the challenged ruling by ordering the confiscation of the seized counterfeit items and the publication of the final conviction summary in two local daily newspapers, in addition to the fine previously imposed on the respondent.
Related judgments
Jurisdiction in Drug Trafficking Cases and the Principle of Non-Retroactivity of Procedural Laws
The Federal Supreme Court
2026
A Procedural Maze: Supreme Court Reverses Conviction to Uphold the Fundamental Right to a Two-Tier Trial
The Federal Supreme Court
2026
Clemency vs. Penalty Substitution: Supreme Court Clarifies Judicial Discretion in Immigration Forgery Case
The Federal Supreme Court
2026