Does Every Use of a Computer Constitute a Cybercrime? A Legal Reading into the Scope of Article 8 of the Law on Combatting Rumors and Cybercrimes
An analytical legal study examining the statutory parameters of Article 8 of the UAE Cybercrime Law, judicial standards regarding offline devices, and distinguishing cyber offences from civil employment disputes.
At a glance
The one-minute summary
- Mere usage of a computer or smartphone is insufficient on its own to characterize an act as a cybercrime.
- The statutory definition of IT means in Article (1) includes standalone offline data storage and processing without requiring internet connectivity.
- Article (8) penalizes unauthorized obtaining, copying, or leaking of confidential data belonging to economic, commercial, or financial entities.
- The Federal Supreme Court (Cassation 976/2022 Penal) affirmed teleological statutory interpretation rather than relying purely on device utilization.
- Conditions governing publicity in insult offences cannot be transposed to the offence of unauthorized trade secret copying without statutory basis.
- Article (8) prescribes severe penalties (at least 5 years imprisonment and fines from AED 500,000 to AED 3,000,000), necessitating strict construction.
- A clear distinction must be maintained between employment or contractual breaches and criminal cyber offences to uphold the legality principle.

Legislative Foundation of IT Means and the Scope of Article 8
Introduction: The Issue of Overextending Cyber Characterization to Physical Acts
Accelerating technological progress raises fundamental legal questions regarding the application boundaries of penal provisions governing information technology crimes: Is the mere use of a computer or smartphone sufficient to confer the classification of a cybercrime upon any act committed through it? Does the act of copying files from a laptop turn into a cybercrime simply because the device employed is considered a modern technological tool? Does the law require the device to be connected to an information network, or is the mere utilization of its offline data storage and processing functions sufficient to trigger statutory application?
Legislative Foundation of IT Means and Article 8
Federal Decree-Law No. (34) of 2021 on Combatting Rumors and Cybercrimes was promulgated to confront various manifestations of criminal conduct associated with the use of information technology. Article (1) of the Decree-Law established an expansive definition of information technology and its means, encompassing devices and instruments utilized for creating, processing, storing, and exchanging electronic data, in addition to information networks and systems.
Within this statutory framework, Article (8) criminalizes several specified acts, including obtaining, acquiring, copying, disclosing, and leaking, whenever committed without authorization in relation to confidential data or information pertaining to a financial, commercial, or economic facility, through the use of information technology or one of its means. Notably, the legislator did not merely define the proscribed act, but expressly stipulated a specific instrumentality for its perpetration, raising crucial legal inquiries into the implications of this restriction and its independence from the mere physical presence of an electronic device at the scene of the incident.